Talent Identification: Trying to Get It Right
Talent identification is one of the most challenging aspects of athlete development. In this section, we explore three key problems that make getting it “right” so difficult—and offer practical recommendations to help you navigate them.
1. Understanding the Current and Future Demands of Sport
Sport performance is multidimensional, encompassing technical, tactical, physical, and psycho-social elements. To identify talent effectively, practitioners must understand these demands—not just as they exist today, but as they may evolve in the future.
Sports change over time. Rules shift, playing styles adapt, and athlete profiles evolve. Predicting what a sport might look like in 10, 15, or 20 years is no easy task—it’s like peering into a crystal ball.
To address this challenge:
- Establish a clear performance model that outlines the key demands of your sport. This provides clarity and consistency in decision-making.
- Anticipate and shape future changes. Visionary coaches often succeed because they imagine and influence how their sport will evolve (Lara-Bercial & Mallett, 2016).
2. Understanding How Young People Grow and Develop
Most talent identification happens with young athletes, making it a complex task. Predicting future adult performance requires understanding the biological, psychological, and social development of young people.
Youth sport is typically structured around age groups, which can unintentionally advantage or disadvantage certain individuals. Two common biases are:
- Relative Age Effect – older children in an age group often perform better.
- Maturity Bias – early developers may be mistaken for more talented athletes.
To mitigate these issues:
- Delay talent identification until after maturity.
- Provide broader development opportunities to ensure no one is overlooked.
3. Making Informed Talent Identification Decisions
Given the complexity of sport and youth development, it’s no surprise that talent identification decisions are often limited in effectiveness. To improve your process, ask yourself:
- When should talent identification begin in your sport?
- Why is it necessary at that point?
Answering these questions helps justify your approach and timing. Additionally, use a multidimensional talent identification tool that includes:
- Objective data (e.g., fitness tests)
- Subjective data (e.g., coach ratings)
- Bio-psycho-social insights
This holistic approach supports more informed and equitable decisions.
Conclusion
To make better talent identification decisions:
- Understand your sport
- Understand young people
- Use a multidimensional tool
- Take your time
By embracing these principles, you’ll be better equipped to identify and nurture talent in a way that supports long-term development and success.
Watch the full video below
Comments
Related Pages